Medical descriptions before Pierre Marie PDF Print E-mail

Chapter 4. - Early medical descriptions of acromegaly (1526 -1885) or Acromegaly in medical literature before Pierre Marie

In Pierre Marie's first article describing acromegalie (Marie P 1886) he cites the cases of five earlier authors Saucerotte N 1801, Nöel 1779, Alibert 1822, Friedrich N 1868, and Henrot H 1882. The three verbal descriptions give some evidence and the two cases Marie describes with the illustrations and description of Friedrich and Henrot probably aided him in his conclusions that acromegaly was a separate disease. The value of photography for his engravings and more especially that of Freidrich is clear.

Illustration from the paper by Friedrich 1868.

Hyperostoses des gesammten Skelettes, Friedrich N 1868.

From the time of Pierre Marie's conclusions, "There exists a disease specially characterised by an hypertrophy of the hands, feet and face, which we propose to call Acromegaly; . . ." (Marie P Souza-Leite 1891), there has been an interest in finding earlier cases in the medical literature that can be attributed to acromegaly.

By the time Suoza-Leite published his thesis on "Marie's Maladie" in 1890 he could include a further 29 cases - 7 of these being earlier cases renamed as acromegaly (Verga, A 1864, Chalk, O 1857, Lombroso, C 1869, Brigidi, V 1877 and 1881, Taruffi, C 1877, 1879 and 1881, Ellinwood, C 1883, Fritshce & Klebs, E 1884).

Plate 1 from the paper by Henrot 1882.Plate 3 from the paper by Henrot 1882.

Des lésions anatomiques et de la nature du myxoedéme, Henrot, H 1882.

" Cases have, however, been confounded under different names, such as general osseus hypertrophy, pachydermatous cachexia, gigantism, exophthalmic cachexia etc . . . . " Souza-Leite 1926 pg 32 of Hutchinsons translation.

These seven together with cases recognised as acromegaly following Marie's initial publication further reinforced acromegaly's claim as a clinical entity. Indeed by 1900 there were a further 658 references to acromegaly published. Atkinson published a definitive work in 1930 containing all the then known references to acromegaly and following on from the 19th century illustrations show the increasing sway of the camera both as a means for producing a clinical record, which was then used as an engraving or in limited editions the prints themselves until the half-tone method of reproduction was cheap enough to be used by the majority of medical journals.

Chronological list of cases

  • 1567 Weiri, Johannes
  • 1779 Nöel (Cited by Pierre-Marie)
  • 1801 Saucerotte, Nicholas (Cited by Pierre-Marie)
  • 1818 Gall, Franz Joseph and Spurzheim, Johannes Caspar
  • 1822 Alibert (Cited by Pierre-Marie)
  • 1823 Rayer, P
  • 1827 Chevalier, TW
  • 1839 Todd, RB
  • 1841 Magendie, M
  • 1857 Chalk, O
  • 1864 Verga, A
  • 1868 Friedrich, N (Cited by Pierre-Marie)
  • 1869 Lombroso, C
  • 1877, 1879 and 1881 Taruffi, C
  • 1877 and 1881 Brigidi, V
  • 1879 Cunningham, DJ
  • 1882 Henrot, H (Cited by Pierre-Marie)
  • 1883 Ellinwood, C
  • 1884 Fritshce & Klebs, E
  • 1885 Wadsworth

Weiri, Johannes 1567

This case is cited by Weinberg in his 1931 paper on Gigantism and Acromegaly (Hyperpituitarism).

In 1567, Johannes Weyer (Wierus), Dutch surgeon and an active opponent of superstition and witch-burning, tells in his "Medicarum Observationumrariorum"; of a giantess he had seen. There is hardly a suggestion of acromegaly but he gives some very interesting speculations as to the cause of the amenorrhea and general apathy found in the case. I will give the account in full;

Moreover in this treatise it is not proper that I should pass over a rare and memorable history, worthy of explanation. I saw a virgin who, because of the gigantic size of her body, travelled to cities in various regions and in those places exhibited herself in hired buildings to all who paid an offering, from which collections she and her mother sought a livelihood. I also, having entered [to see her], inquired by diligent questions and I learned from her replies and those of her mother that she was born of parents both of whom were of short stature and that none of her ancestors exceeded the ordinary height of men and that this girl from the time of her birth to her twelfth year was of small stature: but at the time when she had reached her fourteenth year and had struggled with her menses for some time, they suddenly ceased and she began to increase in size, all of her member proportionately formed so that nothing seemed unusual. Unless I am mistaken, when I saw her she was in the twentyfifth year from the time she had noticed the cessation of her flowing. Nature required that bloody excrement to nourish and conserve so great a mass. She enjoyed good health in the meantime, her form was not attractive, her temperament was simple and stupid and her whole body was sluggish. The physical qualities which God had i'nfused into her body in the beginning, while sufficient for a body of ordinary size, when dispersed afterwards in that vast mass of flesh could not show themselves with the, same strength as they would in a body of ordinary size.

The presence of amenorrhea is a clear sign that the gigantism was due to a pituitary tumour. 

  • 1567
  • Weiri, Johannes
  • Medicarum observationumvararum liber unus.
  • Basiliae per Jannem Oporinum MDLXVII
  • Royal College of Physicians, 9 Queen Street, Edinburgh, EH2 1JQ
  • cf Weinberg SJ 1931 pg 657/8
  • Major finding of significance "no corpore menses"
  • None

Nöel, 1779 

  • 1779
  • Nöel
  • Sur un accroisement considerable des os dans deux personne adulte.
  • Jour de Méd, Par. 51, 225
  • Edin UL, George Sq, Edinburgh, EH8 9LJ
  • Translation in Sammlung Auserlersener Abhandlungen für praktische. Aertze, xv, 541.

Saucerotte, N 1801

Accroissement singulier en grosseur des os d'un homme âgé de 39 ans (*).

II y a environ 6 ans (en 1772) qu'un habitant du village de Mangonville, à quatre Iieues de LuneviIle, åge actueIlement de 39 ans, haut de cinq pieds deux à trois pouces, d'une stature grêle en mince, à l'époque citée d'il y a environ six ans, s'aperçoit que tous les os de son corps, à l'exception peut-être des dents, grossissent peu-à-peu sans saIonger (ceux au moins qui peuvent faire croître un individu en hauteur), de manière qu'il estime présentement avoir les os, au moins du double gros qu'au terme d'il y a six ans.

II est certain que c'est un homme extraordinaire, eu égard à la circonférence de son corps en général, et de chacune de ses parties dans Ie détail, sans que les chairs y soient pour beaucoup: car elles sont flasques et affaissées, et démontrent que c'est aux dépens de leur tissu cellulaire, que les os acquierènt un embonpoint contre nature, s'il est possible de m'exprimer ainsi. Cet homme est obligé de se faire faire des chapeaux, n'en trouvant point dont la forme soit assez ample pour lui; ses yeux sont actuellement très à fleur de tête, par l'épaississement des os de l'orbite, qui ont porté ces organes en dehors; sa mâchoire inférieure ayant sans doute eu plus de facilité à s'étendre que la supérieure, parce qu'elle est un os unique et mobile, il s'ensuit que les dents incisives du bas débordent celles du hant de I'épaisseur d'un doigt: ce qui n'est pas de même pour les dents molaires, sans duote parce que la force des muscles crotaphytes et masseters s'est opposée à I'élargissement de la mâchoire inférieure sur les côtés; la lévre inférieure est peut-être I'unique partie molle qui ait suiyi I'accroissement progressif des parties dures, car elle est trés-grosse; la colonne vertébrale est d'un caIibre singulier; il en est de même des cIavicules; les omplates et les os des hanches ont prodigieusement pris d'étendue et d'épaisseur, de même que les côtes et Ie sternum: de sorte que Ia poitrine est fort éminente, et Ie ventre fort plat, eu égard à l'affaissement et à l'émaciation des parties molles: Les côtes ont bien un pouce et demi de !argeur, et paroissent même, en quelques endroits, déborder les unes sur les autres; les pieds et les mains peuvent être comparés, relativement à la grosseur, à ces mêmes parties, qui, chez un sujet ordinaire, seroient attaquées d'un gonflement, comme on dit à pleine peau; les jambes seules paroissent, à la premiére inspection, ne point cadrer avec Ie reste du corps: mais bientôt I'illusion cesse, si I'on fait attention qu'lles sont tout os, et qu'elles n'ont point ou presque point de molet; malgré cela Ie tendon d'Achille est bien Ie double gros que chez un autre sujet adulte.

Ce citoyen ne peut imputer I'accroissement, de ses os à aucun état maladif; il est vrai que, dans tous les temps, il a été assez gros mangeur: mais aussi il a constamment fait beaucoup d'exercice; car il est un des plus grands cuItivateurs de Ia province. Actuellement il est presque toujours assoupi, sans doute à cause de Ia compression du cerveau, par l'épaississement des os du crâne. Depuis environ deux ans, il éprouve une oppression de poitrine, sans doute aussi par Ia gène où se trouvent les poumons. Je crois qu'il n'est pas inutile de dire que, depuis que celte augmentation est parvenue à un certain point, Ie pouls est constamment si petit qu'on ne peut souvent Ie trouver.

Le malade a pris toutes sortes de remèdes altérans et évacuans, sans pouvoir détourner Ies sues nourriciers de se porter aux os plutôt qu'aux chairs. Mais pourquoi ces sues ont-ils abandonné des canaux flexibles, perméables, et d'une extensibilité facile, pour se rendre dans des tuyaux durs et qui offrent une resistance considérable à Ia dilatabilité? Enfin il ressent, j'oubliois de Ie dire, des douIeurs universelles, qu'il croit être des rhumatismes: mais il est bien plus à présumer qu'elles sont Ie résultat de la distension du périoste et des autres parties membraneuses qui environnent Ies os.

Ne seroit-il pas possible, dans Ie principe, d'une pareille maladie, d'administrer des médicamens qui, par leur analogie avec la substance osseuse, possédassent la vertu d'en expulser les sucs surabondans, et d'établir par ce moyen, l'équilibre dans leur répartition? Toutes ces choses sont des secrets de la nature, dans lesquels nous pénétrerons sans doute tôt ou tard: Ies progrés immenses, que font Ia physique et la chimie, nous en sont garants. Au reste, qui peut mieux dévoiler les routes secrétes de notre mère commune que les membres éclairés de la compagnie célébre à qui j'adresse cette observation.

(*) Ayant envoyé cette observation a l'academie de chirurgie, en 1772, j'en conserYe et en rapporl. toute Ies dates 

  • 1801
  • Saucerotte, Nicholas
  • Accriossement singulier en grosseur des os d'un homme áge de 39 ans.
  • Mélanges de Chirurgie 1: 407-411

  • Observation communicated to Academy of Surgery in 1772 (s.Virchow Gescwülste Bd II, S.24)
  • Description of subject seen in 1772

Gall, Fj Spurzheim, JC 1818

Drawing of an acromegalic skull. Anatomical Atlas. Referred to by Patry FM 1908.

  • 1818
  • Gall, Franz Joseph and Spurzheim, Johannes Caspar
  • Anatomie et physiologie du systéme nerveux en général et du cerveau en particulier. 1810-1819.
  • 1818; 3: 30
  • Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons, 234- 242 St Vincent Street, Glasgow, G2 5RJ
  • Patry FM 1908 L'acromégalie avant 1885.
  • To be obtained

Alibert 1822

No source found for this publication in the UK.

  • 1822
  • Alibert
  • Précis théorique et pratique des maladies de la peau.
  • Par 1822, iii: 317.
  • None found for this publication in UK, via Interlibrary Loans

Rayer, P 1823

  • 1823
  • Rayer, P
  • Observations sur les maladies de l'appendice sus-sphenoidal (glande pituitaire)
  • Arch gén de med 3: 350-67.

Chevalier, TW 1827

Pathology of the Brian

Case 1. Aneurismal Tumour, situated between the Brain and Sella Tursica. By Thomas William Chevalier, Consulting Surgeon to the Royal Union Association, and Surgeon to the Westminster General Dispensary.

S.B. aetat. thirty-nine, a woman of masculaine form and robust constitution, applied to me on the 8th of October, when I obtained the following hislory of her case from herself and her mother: -- She had suffered from a severe burn at the age of fourteen, and had ever since complained of an unusual sensation, which she described as "a shaking movement in her inside." She had been more or less subject to headache from her infancy, and finally ceased to meustruate seven years since, without experiencing any inconvenience.

She had always been fond of reading, and indulged much in that amusement. Her circumstances obliged her to Iead an extremely temperate and laborious life; to which, however, she was cheerfully inclined.

About the month of May last, she first began to be afflicted with a strange sort of headache, very different from that to which she was previously accustomed, and a sensation of burning heat in the stomach, feeling (to use her own expression,) "as if her inside were on fire," and she frequently complained of the escessive heat of her mouth.

Those headaches, which were very severe, usually occurred more than once a week, and lasted, if at night, during two or three hours, but, in the daytime, usually for half an hour.

They were always preceded by fIushing of the countenance, and an increased sensation of heat, particularly in the region of the stomach, withonl any shivering or perspirations. They invariably commenced at the back of the head, the pain shooting through to the right eye, and generally producing oedema of the palpebrae. They were always relieved by the application of cold to the head, and they would at any time recur if she attempted to sit by the fire, or even to expose herself to the heat of the sun.

Her mother informed me that she often seemed to lose her recollection and conciousness for the space of a minute or two during these attacks, and that her health had appeared to decline from last spring, at which time they commenced.

About six weeks since, she remarked that she felt the same kind of "shaking or beating" in her head which until now she had experienced only in her stomach. f'rom this time her head was never entirely free from pain, and her sight became slightly impaired, so that she could not see to thread her needle; and about the same period, while walking on one occasion in Oxford Street, she found herself falling forward to the ground, and would have dropped had she not saved herself by taking hold of the railings. She presently recovered, and returned home, the distance of a furlong, witbout assistance.

Three weeks before she died, she fell upon her face in the street, and remained insensible for a few minutes; after which she was conducted home, with her usual headache. On Monday Octoher 11th, she consented, for the first time, to receeive medical advice, and accompanied her mother to my house, when I obtained the above account. I found that she retained the senses of hearing and smelling unimpaired, as well as her appetite; her sense of taste had heen deranged for months past, but this, proceeded, as she thought, from the heat of her mouth. Her countenance was now strongly marked with despondency, and she exhibited an air of stupid iudifference, which would have induced me to helieve her intoxicated or insane; hut. upon inquiry, I fonnd her intellect perfectly sound, and her hahits of life most abstemious.

Her pulse ninety-six, labouring, but not hard or full; tongue furred; bowels habitually costive; countenance florid. but as if chilled by cold. I prescribed a bluepill every night, and a compound, colocynth pill every morning, and ordered her to he cupped on the back of the neck to sixteen ounces.

On the following morning she was much relieved, and enlivened in her general appearance.

On Tuesday night, howerer, the pain in the head recurred with increased violence, accommpanied by sickness, and continued nearly all night.

In the morning I found her cheerful, and rather improved than otherwise in every respect. To take one ounce of Epsom salts tomorrow morning. and to continue the pills.

Ocloher 19th. --- She went to bed Iast night tolerably well. At half-past one o'clock. however, she got out of bed. and awaked her mother, who inquired what she was doing? to which question she replied, that she was opening the shutters to admit the light, because the room was so dark; whereas there was a candle burning in the room,and no shutters whatever to the window. Her mother arose in time to prevent her falling to Ihe ground, and replaced her in bed.

From this time she became comatose. and I was sent for in the forenoon. I found her perfectly devoid of intellect. but almost entirely deprived of sensation and voluntary motion; with a small, rapid, and labouring pulse: the feet cold: the pupil small and fixed; the countenance not in the least distorted; the breathing rather laborious, but not otherwise unnatural. She shrunk from the examination of the pupil, but evinced no other sign of senation.

To be cupped twelve ounces immediately, and a large blister applied to Ite back of the neck. Spirit lotion to the head; and an enema of compound of Colocynth and gruel as soon as possible.

At noon she appeared a little revived from Ihe cupping, and uttered a word or two upon being disturbed: her pulse had, however, increased in frequency, with scarcely any augmentation of its strength; and she died at one o'clock on the following morning, without having manifested any return of conciousness, or exhibited any other symptoms than those of pure coma.

Dissection. -- There were extensive cicatrices opon the arms, neck and chest. One side of the thorax was considerably depressed by a distortion of many years standing, but the Iungs were free from any unnatural adhesion, and every part of the trunk perfectly heathy.

On opening the head, the vessels of the meninges appeared rather turgid, and an extravasation of recent blood was found beneath the left parietal bone, between the arachnoid membrane and the pia mater, but its quantity did not exceed a table-spoonful, and was diffused over a circular space of three inches diameter.

The substance of the brain was unusually firm and healthy. The ventricles contained no more than about one fluid drachm of clear serum.

Upon raising the encephalon from the base of the skull, there was discovered a tumor of the size of a large walnut, attached to the pia mater of the base of the brain, and altogether inseparable without violence, from the sella tursica, so that an attempt was made to remove the adjacent bone, together with the brain, but without success, in consequence of the restraint which the presence of friends imposed. The soft parts being at length separated, the base of the tumor appeared to have filled the sella tursica, which was left clean by its removal, and its chief bulk had been situated so as to separate the corpora albicantia and the optic nerves more than an inch and a quarter from the posterior clinoid processes.

The tumor itself was nearly spherical, inclosed in a fine transparent membrane, excepting where it was cut away from the bone, and of so firm a texture that I was induced to believe it solid throughout. Upon cutting into it. however, after it had been macerated in alcohol for four or five days, I found it to consist entirely of coagula of blood, deposited in several distinct layers, which, like those of an aneurism, were paler on one side, viz. towards the bone, and softer as they approached the corpora albicantia, where there was a cavity as large as a filbert, containing recent coagulum.

With the utmost pains, I have been unable to detect any direct communication between the tumor and the adjacent arterial trunks: three or four comparatively minute branches of the left anastomosing artery of the circle of Willis are, however, so closely connected with its membranous envelope, that one of these may probably have furnished its contents. The preparation not having been injected, it is impossible to determine this point as accurately as might be desired. I hope, however, that the accoullt here given may not be altogether useless, as the symptoms described were sufficient to creale a suspicion in my mind from the first, of the true nature of the disease, and enabled me to fortel to a medical friend the result of the dissection with tolerable accuracy. 20, Soouth Audley Street; November 12th, 1827.

  • 1827
  • Chevalier, TW
  • Case 1. Aneurismal Tumour, situated between the Brain and Sella Tursica.
  • London Medical and Physical Journal, 58: 498-501

Todd, RB 1839

Abnormal conditions of the bones of the face

In Corvisart's Journal de Médecine the case of a Moor is cited, whose head and face were so enormous that he could not stir abroad without being followed by the populace.It is related that the nose of this man, who was half an idiot, was four inches long, and his mouth so large that he would bite a melon in the proportion that an ordinary person would eat an apple.

I have now before me the skull of a native of Shields who was remarkable during life for the length of his face; the entire head is large, but the bones of the face, and particularly the lower jaw, are enormously long. The abnormal development of the facial bones generally affects one jaw only, and more frequently the lower, as in the example just mentioned.

  • 1839
  • Todd, RB
  • Abnormal conditions of the bones of the face.
  • Encyclopaedia of anatomy and physiology 2: 219.
  • See above
  • None

Magendie, M 1841

Leçons sure les fonctions et les maladies du système nerveux.

Une activité extraordinaire de la nutrition est en général liée à une état particulier du système nerveux. Etat particulier, c' est un mot. bien vague; mais je ne puis vous donner cette assertion que comme conjecturale et par conséquent vous me permetirez de ne point me servir de termes trop positifs. Toujours est-il que j'ai dans ce moment-ci à l'Hôtel-Dieu deux femines offrant à son maximum de développement cette maniére d'étre de l'economie qu'on est convenu d'appeler hypertrophie. L'une est une vraie femme-monstre. Tête, membre, tronc, tout a un volume énorme; sa langue a la largeur de celle du veau. ses doigts sont gros comme quatre des miens. Sa voix est celle d'un homme; les sons en sont graves, pleins: je ne doute pas que Ie larynx ne soit aussi hypertrophié. L'autre femme est dans le même genre, seulement elle a un peu moins d'ampleur. Comme elle est plus jeune, et que chaque jour elIe gagne davantage. je ne doute pas qu'avant peu elle ne puisse rivaliser avec son ainée. Rien d'ailleurs chez ces deux femmes n'explique cet accroissement énorme. Il est probable que Ia système nerveux y est pour beacoup.

Un fait incontestable c'est que la cessation de l'influence nerveuse amène des altérations profondes dans la nutrition, Vous verrez bientôt sur l'animal vivant la section d'un des nerfs de la cinquième paire être suivie de l'atrophie, du ramollissement, de la fonte purulente de toute la moitié correspondante de la face, tandis que l'autre moitié continue vivre, sans présenter la moindre lésion.

Ce n'est pIus seulement sur les autres orgnes, c'est sur lui-même que nous verrons Ie système nerveux influer. Ainsi tel nerf n'est pas sensible, isole est en realtion avec tel autre nerf. L'expérience directe prouve ces singulières dépendances. Irritez la septième paire, l'animal manifeste de lasouffrance tant que la cinquiéme paire est intacte: celle-ci a telle été coupée dans le crane, de manière que toute communication anastomotique soit détruite entre elle et la septième paire, vous aurez beau irriter celte septième paire, l'animal ne souffre plus. Ici donc la sensibilité ou l'insensibilité d'un nerf dépend de ce qu'il est ou de ce qu'il n'est plus en rapport avec un autre nerf.

Nous verrons aussi que bien qu'un nerf spécial soit affecté à chaque sens, il faut Ie concours d'un autre nerf pour que ce sens fonctionne normalement. II est dans ce cas fort difficile de faire la part de chaque nerf. Vous coupez la cinquiéme paire et l'animal a perdu I'ouie, la vue et l'odorat. Cependant les nerfs acoustique, optique et olfactif n'ont subi aucune atteinte. Ces nerfs ne sont donc pas exclusivement les nerfs propres de I'organe: iIs ne remplissent pas seuls Ies fonctions du sens dont ils ont reçu Ie nom. Peut-être même, et nous Ie vérifierons, Ie nerf olfactif n'accomplit-il pas relativement à I'odorat les usages qu'on est habitué à lui reconnaitre. Ce sera une question très intéressante à examiner de nouveau devant vous.

II n'est donc aucune fonction, aucun phénomène où vous ne retrouviez Ie système nerveux. Si nous comparans notre petit monde au grand, nous y reconnaissons la même harmonie, et alors, empruntant quelque chose à une pensée sublime, nous pourrions définir Ie système nerveux un centre dont la circonférence est partout.

II nous sera impossible de donner à ces études toule I'extension, tous les développements qu'elles comportent. Ce que je veux, c'est d'établir avec vous quelques propositions fondamentales basées
sur une saine physiologic. Si de là nous avons Ie temps de faire quelque excursion dans Ie domaine de Ia pathologie, nous serons d'autant plus en mesure que souvent dans les maladies vous reconnaîtrez la main de I'expérimentateur, dans l'homme qui souffre, I'animal chez lequel vous déterminez à votre gré de semblables souffrances. Une personne est frappée d'une hémorrhagic cérébrale. Elle perd certaine faculté. Quel est Ie point du cerveau qui a été atteint? Vous répondrez sans hésiter, et désignerez hardiment le siége de Ia lésion, si dans vos expériences du laboratoire, vous avez reconnu l'endroit qu'il faut blesser pour développer de semblables phénomenès.

Élevant plus haut vos prétentions, ne tenterez vous pas de connaître quels rapprochements on peut établir entre I'état du cerveau et certaines manières d'être de I'intelligence? Voici sur cette table Ie cerveau d'une femme aliénée; à côté est celui d'une femme morte avec toute la plénitude de sa raison; examinez, comparez, où est la différence? Permettez-moi une remarque. On se fait en général des idées fort inexactes de l'aliénation mentale en se la figurant comme un état permanent d'agitation et d'exaltation. C'est cependant le cas Ie plus rare. La plupart des aliénés sont mornes, taciturnes, dans un état d'affaissement général: ce n' est que par accès, alors que quelque chose a exalté leurs idées, ou évellé d'irritants souvenirs, qu'ils s'emportent, et que leur imagination s'exaspére. Meurent-ils dans cette période, vous trouvez la pie-mère injectée, la substance grise des circonvolutions parcourue par plus de sang; mais, prenez garde; cette congestion n' est qu'un effet. Elle n'a point appelé la folie, mais elle a été appelée par elle. Qu'un homme sain d'esprit, d'un naturel calme, soit pris d'une violente colère, et expire au milieu d'une exaltation extrême, vous retrouverez dans son cerveau les mêmes lésions que chez l'alièné. Sera-ce donc ici l'injection de la substance cérébrale qui aura provoqué cette espèce d'aliénation d'un moment?

Voici ençore une leçon toute consacrée à des généralités. C'est que Ie sujet est si abondant, qu'il nous enlraine; si vaste, qu'on ne peut l'embrasser ni Ie restreindre. J'espère cependant qu'à notre prochaine réunion nous pourrons vous donner quelques idées générales de la disposition et de Ia structure du système nerveux. 

  • 1841
  • Magendie, M
  • Leçons sur les fonctions et les maladies du systéme nerveux
  • Paris, i, 34ff
  • Photocopy
  • 2 cases female maximum development of their hands. Case 1 Truly monstrous woman, large head, limbs, trunk, enormous volume. French as above.

Chalk, O 1857

Illustration from the paper by Chalk, O 1857 showing a cast of the jaws right lateral view.

Partial dislocation of the lower jaw from an enlarged tongue, Chalk O 1857. 

  • 1857
  • Chalk, O
  • Partial dislocation of the lower jaw from an enlarged tongue.
  • Trans Path Soc Lon 1856; Lon 1857; 8: 305-
  • Line drawing of maxilla and mandible showing extent of dislocation.

 Verga, A 1864

Negative to be scanned - Verga, A. Caso singolare di prospectasia. Rendiconti del Reade Instituti di Scienze Lettre di lombardo, Milano. 1864; 3: 111-7.

  • 1864
  • Verga, A
  • Caso singolare di prospectasia
  • Rendiconti del Reade Instituti di Scienze Lettre di lombardo, Milano. 1864; 3: 111-7.
  • Belloni L. Il quadro anatomico-clinico della acromegalia descritto da Andrea Verga nel 1864. Atti della Academia Medica Lombarda 1964; 19: 1363-79.
  • Translation Nouvelle Iconographie de la Salpêtrière 1864; 1: ? - ?; Reprint facsimilie. Belloni L. Il quadro anatomico-clinico della acromegalia descritto da Andrea Verga nel 1864. Atti della Academia Medica Lombarda 1964; 19: 1363-79.

Friedrich, N 1868

Hyperostoses des gesammten Skelettes, Friedrich, N 1868.

Hyperostoses des gesammten Skelettes, Friedrich, N 1868. 

  • 1868
  • Friedrich, N
  • Hyperostoses des gesammten Skelettes.
  • Virchow's Archiv fur Pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie ude fur Klinische Medizin 43: 83-7
  • Engraving or lithograph from a photograph or illustration?

Lombroso, C 1869

Illustration from the paper by Lombroso, C 1869.

Merkurürdiger Fall von allgemeiner hypertrophie (Macrosomia) oder scheinbarer elephantiasis, Lombroso, C 1869. 

  • 1869
  • Lombroso, C
  • Merkurürdiger Fall von allgemeiner hypertrophie (Macrosomia) oder scheinbarer elephantiasis.
  • Virchow's Archiv fur Pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie ude fur Klinische Medizin 46: 253-6.
  • Translation Caso singolare di macrosomia. Giov Ital delle malattie venere, Milano 1868. No location UK.
  • Three illustrations: face, part of nervous system and variety of small pictures including hand and jaw.

Taruffi, C 1877, 1879 and 1881

Museum of Anatomical Pathology of Bologna. Number 593. Skeleton of acromegalic giant?

  • 1877, 1879 and 1881
  • Taruffi, C
  • Scheletro bolognese con prospoectasia e tredici vertebre dorsali.
  • Annali Universali di Medicina e Chirurgica, Milano. 1879; 247: 339 - 88
  • Photocopy. Royal Society of Medicine, Wimpole Street. London.
  • Others Memorie della Reale Accad delle Sceinze dell'Instituto di Bologna 1877 Series 3, 10: 63 ff. Not available UK.
  • 4 figures. Did not come with photocopy.

Brigidi, V 1877 and 1881

This case is described completely by Dr Brigidi of Florence including autopsy. He diagnosed it as Rheumatitis deformans and made a significant observation of a hypertrophied pitutitary gland together with the first microscopic examination of a pituitary tumour.

The case described is that of the actor Ghirlenzoni. Michel Casini, surgeon of Florence knew Ghirlenzoni after 1835 he was previously known for his romantic roles. He attempted to commit suicide in the Arno on 27th August 1875. He was carried to hospital delerious and lapsed into a coma.

  • 1877 and 1881
  • Brigidi, V
  • Studii anatomopatologica sopra un uomo divenuto stranamente deforme par chronica infirmità.
  • Società medico-fisica Fiorentina, 1877. Not available UK. or Arch d Scuola D'Anat Patol. Firenze,1881; 1: 63 - 94
  • Patry, M 1905. Acromegaly avant Pireer Marie, Thesis for Doctorate.
  • Patry, M 1905, Weinberg SJ. 1931
  • Patry includes Brigidi's full description inlcuding illustration of base of brain including sella turcica.
  • Only photocopy obtained not good enough for reproduction.

Cunningham, DJ 1879

Illustration of brain from an acromegalic shwon in right profile to show the position of the cyst, Cunningham, DJ 1879.

A large sub-arachnoid cyst involving the greater part of the parietal lobe of the brain.

  • 1879
  • Cunningham, DJ
  • A large sub-arachnoid cyst involving the greater part of the parietal lobe of the brain.
  • J Anat Phys 1879; 13: 508-17.
  • Diagram of brain with cyst. Post mortem examination

Henrot, H 1882

Henrot, H 1882, Plate 1Henrot, H 1882. Plate 3Henrot, H 1882, Plate 2

Des lésions anatomiques et de la nature du myxoedéme, Henrot, H 1882.

  • 1882
  • Henrot, H
  • Des lésions anatomiques et de la nature du myxoedéme.
  • Reims.
  • Mentioned by Cunningham DJ 1879.
  • Hypertrophie générale progressive. Notes de clinique méd. Reims 1877, 56
  • 3 plates

Ellinwood, C 1883

Osteitis Deformans (case presented before the San Francisco County Medical Society)

This rare disease finds no place in our text-books. For its name and description we are indebted to Sir James Paget. In the case here presented for your examination we have a man of twenty-eight years of age, whose youth was delicate, without any hereditary disease known. At the age of 21 his weight was 93 pounds; at 26, his weight was 206 pounds, and now, at 28, his weight is 196 pounds. He has always been able to work. though at times he experienced muscular weakness, malaise and darting pains in the legs, and notably in the knees. His greatest trouble has been in mastication and dyspepsia.

About a year ago he found his lower jaw protrudiug beyond the upper, which gradually increased until he could not bite his food, and his lower teeth were extracted and a plate of artificial teeth substituted; this soon had to be replaced by another, and still the jaw continuing to elongate, the upper teeth were extracted, and artificial ones adjusted farther forward to fit tbe lower ones, and now you observe that the deformity is yet going on, and the lower teeth are projected nearly an inch beyond the upper. You observe aIso, the bones of the face widening, and, in fact, the entire skull has so enlarged as to require a larger hat, than a year ago. The bones of the trunk, the sternum and ribs, are enlarged, thickened, and the spine shows that deformity called lordosis, and for which he wears a jacket, with benefit from a support. The bones of the hands, the phalanges of the fingers, you see, are quite thickened, and yet flrm and strong. The whole skeleton is undoubtedly affected by the disease, while the head and short bones show it most. On getting out of bed in the morning his joints crack, and are badly adjusted, requiring considerable manipulation to get them to function properly. The man is awkward, and stumbles easily, from the imperfect use of his joints. He is anemic, and suffers very much from the cold weather; his hands become blanched, and his lips are pale, but less so now since his improved nutrition. He is quite free from cerebral symptoms, no headache, mind clear and memory good. His urine shows usually an increased quantity of urates only. At no time has this man had symptoms of acute arthritis.

So far as I can judge of the condition of the bones, they are not porous, they are not light in weight; they are symmetrically enlarged, and only the spine is curved, or its natural curves are greatly exaggerated.

Sir James Paget points out the marked features of other diseases of the bones which distinguished them from osteitis deformans, as in "rachitis, the bones are too small, too short, and have different curves from the elongated and thickened bones of this disaease; and in osteo-malacia they are thin and bent in an angular manner.

The treatment which I have adopted in this case is dietetic; a small allowance of histogenetic food, believing that we have a superabundance of such element in the bones, and giving him, a liberal diet of respiratory food, including cod-liver oil. His digestion has notably improved and his anemia is less marked, and his general condition has evidently improved with this change in diet. He now goes to the mountains for a time with the hope of further improving his nutrition, but we shall again, have him under observation when he returns.

  • 1883
  • Ellinwood, C
  • Osteitis deformans
  • San Francisco Western Lancet 5: 12
  • Photocopy

Fritsche and Klebs, E 1884

Illustration showing the Giant Peter Rhymer facing forwards from the paper by Fritsche and Klebs, E 1884Illustration showing the Giant Peter Rhymer facing to the left from the paper by Fritsche and Klebs, E 1884Drawing of the skull from Peter Rhymer in profile from Fritsche and Klebs, E 1884

Ein beitrag zur pathologie des resisenwuchs, Fritsche and Klebs, E 1884. Giant Peter Rhymer. 

  • 1884
  • Fritshce & Klebs, E
  • Ein beitrag zur pathologie des resisenwuchs.
  • Klinische und pathologischanatomische untersuchungen, Leipzig 1884
  • Photographs of plates

Wadsworth, O 1885

A case of myxodema with atrophy of the optic nerves

It is only quite recently that the disease known as myxoedema has excited much attention; its pathology, beyond the fact that there is a deposit of mucine in the subcutaneous tissues, is still unknown; and even the symptoms observed in the cases reported have presented in some respects considerable variations. Although symptoms pointing to discturbance of the central nervous system have occurred in some cases, no affection of the eyes, in particular the optic nerves, has, so far as I am aware, been described. It may therefore be of interest to put on record the following case, in which there was atrophy of the optici. It may well be that the optic atrophy was only coincident, and had no direct connection with the myxoedema. Yet primary atrophy, as this evidently was, when it affects both eyes, is of comparatively seldom occurrence as an independent lesion.

Mrs C., aged forty-two, a large, strongly built woman, applied to me at the Boston City Hospital, June 27, 1884, because of failure of sight. She was in fairly comfortable circumstances, and since an attack of measles when fourteen years of age, had never been sick. She had been married twelve or fifteen years, but never been pregnant. Her catamenia had been regular till three years ago, when they ceased.

Some seven years ago her fingers and hands, and two or three years later her feet and lower part of her face, lips, nose and eyelids began to increase in size. The enlargement gradually became greater, and for a long time she had been obliged to have her boots made for her, being unable to find any large enough. Her speech became somewhat thick and slow, and her movements slower than formerly. Except for an occasional feeling of numbness in the parts affected, and of burning in the feet and legs, there had been no special discomfort. Of late, however, she had experienced slight dyspnoea on active exertion. Failure of sight was first noticed a year and a half ago, and had continually progressed. Careful inquiry both of her and her husband failed to elicit any history of pains anywhere. She had never had a headache. There had been no failure of intelligence or memory. Her appetite was good, bowels somwhat sluggish, micturition normal. She slept heavily.

The lower part of her face was full, heavy, of waxen hue, the natural folds obliterated; the lips full; the nose large, its alae broad and thick; the eyelids baggy. the hands and fingers were large and square, the thickening being most pronounced on the palmar surface, where the tissues could be pinched up in thick folds and gave the feeling as of an excessive development of subcutaneous fat. The feet were very large and broad, the swelling not extending above the ankles, and , although thre were large varicose veins of the right leg, there was no pitting here or elsewhere. The tongue was large and rather pale. The skin was not dry to the touch, but she stated that she never perspired. The thyroid was of normal size. Auscultation revealed nothing abnormal in heart or lungs. Temperature and pulse were normal. The patellar-tendon reflex was present. There was no significant anaesthesia of the skin. The urine was normal in every respect .

Examination of the eyes showed conjunctiva, cornea and iris to be normal. Movements good. R. only perception of light. L V. = 20/40; F. contracted in all directions, but to a much greater degree upward and outward. Media clear. In both eyes the discs were sharply defined gray with slight bluish tinge, without vascularity; the eeutral vessels, botb arteries and veins, small; in other respects tbe fundus normal.

Some weeks later the patient was admitted to the hospital, in the nervous and renal department, and remained for about a montb. During this time her general condition remained the same, but the vision of the left eye varied somewhat; on September 9 it was recorded as 20/70, but wben I saw her last, at tbe end of September, and a fortnigbt after she had left the bospital, it was 20/40 - 20/50. No farther symptoms had developed.

Read before the American Ophthalmological Society

  • 1885
  • Wadsworth, O. F
  • A case of myxoedema with atrophy of the optic nerves.
  • Boston Med & surg J 112: 5-6
  • Photocopy, courtesy of Boston Medical Library.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Tags See All Tags Add New Tag...

Please Enter New Tags Separated By Comma's
  Or Close



 

Medical history bookstore